Machine Design
  • Resources
  • Members
  • Directory
  • Webinars
  • WISE
  • CAD Models
  • Advertise
    • Search
  • 3D Printing & CAD
  • AUTOMATION & IIOT
  • Robotics
  • Motion Systems
  • Materials
  • Video
  • Data Sheets
  • Topics
    Industry Markets3D Printing & CADAutomation & IIoTFastening & JoiningMaterialsMechanical & Motion Systems Medical DesignRobotics
    Resources
    Machine Design ResourcesWISE (Workers in Science & Engineering)Company DirectorySearch Data SheetsContributeDigital Edition ArchivesCSIA Exchange
    Members
    ContentBenefitsSubscribe
    Advertise
    https://www.facebook.com/MachineDesignMagazine/
    https://www.linkedin.com/company/10998894
    https://twitter.com/MachineDesign
    https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXKEiQ9dob20rIqTA7ONfJg
    Portescap
    Cutaway of a Portescap BLDC
    1. Mechanical & Motion Systems

    Understanding Losses in BLDC Motors

    Sept. 20, 2022
    Engineers who have a firm handle on losses in BLDC motors can better design efficient motors for their specific applications.
    Samuel Klein

    READ MORE

    What Determines the Stall Torque of Brushless DC Motors?

    The Advantages of Slotless Motors over Standard BLDC Motors

    Running Brushed DC Motors as Generators

    Brushless DC (BLDC) motors transform electrical power into mechanical power. However, there’s no such thing as a perfect motor; there are always losses in the transformation. The three main types of losses created during the conversion are friction losses, copper losses and iron losses.

    Portescap
    This cutaway of a Portescap BLDC motor shows where various losses arise and the pathway from electrical to mechanical power (Electrical power − (Friction losses + Copper losses + Iron losses ) = Mechanical power).
    This cutaway of a Portescap BLDC motor shows where various losses arise and the pathway from electrical to mechanical power (Electrical power − (Friction losses + Copper losses + Iron losses ) = Mechanical power).

    Friction losses are caused by the ball and bush bearings, and they are function of the application’s use (speed, load and acceleration) and environment (temperature, dirt and other factors), plus the bearing’s intrinsic characteristics such as material, wear, lubricants and sealing.

    Copper losses, also called joule losses, are created by the coil’s resistance. Torque is linearly proportional to the current, so the more torque a motor provides, the higher the copper losses. This follows the quadratic function shown here:

    Copper Losses = R × I2

    R is resistance and I is current.

    Keep in mind that the resistance will increase as the motor heats up (according to the equation below). This will reduce the efficiency.

    R = R0 × (1 + (𝑦 × ΔTemp))

    R0 is the resistance value at ambient (usually listed in the datasheet), and 𝑦 is resistance factor of copper (0.004/°C).

    Iron losses can be easily misunderstood but they have a substantial effect on motor performance. The losses depend greatly on the frequency of the variation of the magnetic flux into a material, so more losses are generated the faster a motor rotates.

    A small experiment can explain this phenomenon. When a magnet is thrown into a slightly ferromagnetic tube—like copper or aluminum—the speed of the falling magnet is much lower than what would be expected.

    Why does this happen?

    Lenz’s Law states that:

    Induced EMF = −Δɸ/Δ𝑡

    Δɸ is the rate of change in magnetic flux and Δ𝑡 is the corresponding change in time.

    According to Lenz’s law, when the magnet falls through the tube, the changing magnetic field induces current that flows in a direction that opposes the change in the magnetic field that produced it, thereby reducing the magnet’s speed.

    Portescap
    This image illustrates Lenz’s law as demonstrated by a magnet falling into a copper tube.
    This image illustrates Lenz’s law as demonstrated by a magnet falling into a copper tube.

    Iron losses are generated by two phenomena: eddy currents and hysteresis.

    Eddy currents. Faraday’s law states that a magnetic field interacting with a conductor induces a current through it. And, since the material has a specific electrical resistance, it creates some iron losses (R × I2). So eddy current are calculated using:

    Eddy current losses = R × I2 ≅ C × B2 × 𝑓2 × 𝑡2 × V

    Where: C is a constant depending on the motor design and materials; B is the magnetic field into the materials (T); 𝑓 is the frequency of magnetic reversal per second (Hz); 𝑡  is the material’s thickness (m); and V is the volume of the conductor (m3)

    The previous formula shows the parameters that play a large role in creating eddy current losses above. Not surprisingly, the frequency of magnetic field reversal has a substantial influence, as does the motor’s speed. The intensity of the magnetic field and even the thickness of the material also play important roles.

    Portescap
    Tv G3 Losses

    An effective way to reduce the impact of the material’s thickness is by laminating the core material (as shown in the image above). This creates a shorter path for the current to travel through, thereby splitting it into several small currents. Because losses are created with the squared value of the current, this approach is highly effective. So, to avoid current flowing between two laminations, insulate the laminations from each other with a coating.

    Hysteresis. When the magnetic flux is reversed into a ferromagnetic material, energy is lost as the material magnetizes and demagnetizes. To remove the remaining flux density, an opposite magnetic flux should pass the point of coercivity (as shown below).

    Portescap
    Hysteresis loop—the path of magnetization and demagnetization.
    Hysteresis loop—the path of magnetization and demagnetization.

    These losses depend primarily on the magnetic induction in the circuit, but also on material properties such as permeability, volume and the flux variation’s frequency. That’s why it is important to select the right material for the right speed.

    The Steinmetz equation can be used to calculate hysteresis losses and understand the influence of each parameter. It states:

    Hysteresis losses = k × V × 𝑓 × B × n

    Where k is a constant of the material; V is the volume of the magnetic circuit (m3); 𝑓 is the magnetic field’s frequency; B is the maximum induction in the magnetic circuit (T) and n is a coefficient (between 1.6 and 2) that depends on the material

    Getting the Right Motor

    An BLDC motor’s various limit its maximum power, since it would burn if it exceeded a specific temperature depending on the motor design. This makes it critical to select the right motor based on the specific torque-speed working point.

    Copper losses are mainly created when the motor is generating torque, and iron losses usually occur at high speeds. Consequently, the figure below shows that for a given motor, the maximum possible continuous torque decreases when speed increases.

    Portescap
    This graph shows the effect of iron losses on the power curve of a BLDC motor, the Portescap 16ECS36.
    This graph shows the effect of iron losses on the power curve of a BLDC motor, the Portescap 16ECS36.

    Changing the number of poles of a magnet can have a major influence on motor performance. Typically, long motors have two-pole magnets and can run at high speeds. Although this can increase the motor’s maximum torque, it also increases iron losses and thus reduces the maximum continuous speed.

    Iron losses depend highly on the frequency of variation of magnetic flux for a similar speed, so increasing the number of poles increases the number of variations for one motor turn. For eddy current losses, this happens with the square of the increased frequency and can quickly reduce a motor’s efficiency.

    Portescap
    This graph shows the power curves, including losses, of two Portescap motors with different number of poles operating continuously in air at 25°C. The four-pole motor, a torque-optimized 22ECT60 (red), quickly loses torque capabilities as speed increases compared to the two-pole 22ECS60 speed-optimized motor (black).
    This graph shows the power curves, including losses, of two Portescap motors with different number of poles operating continuously in air at 25°C. The four-pole motor, a torque-optimized 22ECT60 (red), quickly loses torque capabilities as speed increases compared to the two-pole 22ECS60 speed-optimized motor (black).

    When selecting an electric motor, it is critical that engineers consider the different losses. Because the motor’s limits are thermal, iron losses play a role in the motor’s efficiency, especially at high speeds or in multipolar, high-torque designs. Optimizing the ratio between copper and iron losses will save energy and improve motor designs.

    Samuel Klein is an application engineer at Portescap.

    Continue Reading

    Brushed vs Brushless Motors: Which is Best for your Application?

    Q&A: Enhancing Performance and Versatility with Advanced 3D Printing Materials

    Sponsored Recommendations

    Smart Factory Solutions that Connect and Protect from Amphenol RF

    Nov. 28, 2023

    Stay Connected and In Control of Your Future Factories with Littelfuse

    Nov. 28, 2023

    Turn to NKK Switches for the Widest Range of Industrial-Savvy Electromechanical Switches

    Nov. 28, 2023

    Unlocking Operational Flexibility in Manufacturing with Industria IoT

    Nov. 28, 2023

    Voice your opinion!

    To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Machine Design, create an account today!

    I already have an account

    New

    A Beginner’s Guide to Design Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (DFMEA)

    Deliver Robust Automated Systems Through Servo Maintenance

    How a Connected World Requires Product Adaptation and Faster Time-to-Market

    Most Read

    For Better or For Worse, Multimodal AI Cultivates New Frontiers

    Brushed vs Brushless Motors: Which is Best for your Application?

    Why it’s Time to Replace Hydraulic and Pneumatic Actuators with Electric Cylinders

    Sponsored

    Industrial Foot Switches

    Inductive Sensors

    Enclosure Materials Available for Rough Environments

    Machine Design
    https://www.facebook.com/MachineDesignMagazine/
    https://www.linkedin.com/company/10998894
    https://twitter.com/MachineDesign
    https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXKEiQ9dob20rIqTA7ONfJg
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Do Not Sell or Share
    • Privacy & Cookie Policy
    • Terms of Service
    © 2023 Endeavor Business Media, LLC. All rights reserved.
    Endeavor Business Media Logo