Eccentric Loading Shouldn’t Mean Shorter Life

April 10, 2008
Take off-center forces into account when estimating the life of linear-motion systems.

Chris Blaszczyk
Manager of Product Development
Automation Components Div.
Misumi USA
Schaumburg, Ill.

Edited by Jessica Shapiro

The life of components in linear-motion systems (LMS) was discussed previously (Machine Design, Dec. 13, 2007, pp. 84-87). The systems represented in that article were assumed to be centrally loaded. While on-axis loading assumptions can be used to estimate the life of systems with off-axis loading, the equations in this article will further refine the accuracy of component-life predictions for systems with noncentral loads.

Horizontal Axis
When the load acting on a horizontal LMS is offset from the axis of motion and from the center of the system, the load doesn’t transmit equally to all four loading points. The points closer to the acting load take a larger portion of the load; the points further from the acting load are unloaded accordingly.

The loads on points 1 through 4 are then given by:

P1 = W/4 + (x0W)/(2X) + (y0W)/2Y

P2 = W/4 - (x0W)/(2X) + (y0W)/2Y

P3 = W/4 + (x0W)/(2X) - (y0W)/2Y

P4 = W/4 - (x0W)/(2X) - (y0W)/2Y

Where Pi= the load on each corner of the LMS, W = applied load, X = total length of the system in the direction of motion, Y = total length of the system perpendicular to the direction of motion, and x0 and y0are the offsets of the acting load from the center point of the system.

If c1 is the dynamic load rating of the individual rollers on a two-shafted system like the one depicted here, the dynamic load rating is:

Cs = 2.88 c1

The life of each roller can then be calculated by:

L = 50 [(ftCs)/(fwPi)] 10/3

where ft = the temperature coefficient for temperatures over 100°C and fw = the load coefficient based on the type of application. Common values of the load coefficient can be found in the previous article.

Vertical axis
In the case of vertical shafts where a downward force is counteracted by an upward thrust, the rollers see forces in the two directions perpendicular to the axis of motion. The loads on the points are as follows:

P1 = P2 = P3 = P4 = (l1W)/(2X)

P1s = P2s = P3s = P4s = (y0W)/(2X)

where l1 = the distance between the point of application of the thrust and the point of application of the downward force out of the shafts’ plane, and y0 is the distance between the midpoint between the two shafts and the location of the downward force. The thrust is assumed to be applied at the center point of the system although it may be out of the shafts’ plane. After calculating the load on each support point, you can calculate the life span as above.

Right angles to horizontal
When the system is oriented such that the shaft axis is horizontal and the load is downward, perpendicular to the axis of motion, there are three sets of loads to be considered. The out-of-plane loads are the same as in the vertical axis case above. The in-plane loads for the points closer to the load-application point are:

P1s = P3s = W/4 + (x0W)/(2X)

The in-plane loads for the points further from the point of load application are:

P2s = P4s = W/4 - (x0W)/(2X)

Once again, these loads can be converted into lifespan estimates as above.

Acceleration and Deceleration
Even if the applied load acts on the center point of an LMS, the load becomes unevenly distributed on the four rolling points during acceleration and deceleration. In a horizontal double-shaft system in which a downward force is applied at the center point, the force on each rolling point is W/4 at rest and at constant speed. During acceleration, the force on the lagging rollers is:

P1 = P3 = W/4 [1 + (2V1l1)/(gt1X)]

The force on the leading rollers is:

P2 = P4 = W/4 [1 - (2V1l1)/(gt1X)]

In these equations, V is the speed at the end of the acceleration in mm/sec, l1 is the vertical distance between the application of the load and the application of the thrust, g is the gravitational constant, 9.8 x 103 mm/sec2, t is the time in seconds over which the system accelerated, and X is the linear system span in the axial direction.

When decelerating the equations are the same, except that the leading rollers take the higher than average load. For off-axis loading systems, combine the acceleration equations with those above that fit the system. The loads obtained can be used to calculate an average load on each roller over a lifetime of starting and stopping before plugging the average into the lifeprediction calculations.

Make Contact
Misumi USA,

The load, acting and distances from the center of the system, applies a different force to each of the four rollers.p>

The load acts from the center point of the system and the load and thrust are separated by. The load is applied to each of the four system points equally, but with both in-plane and out-of-plane components.

The load acts from the center point of the system and out of plane. The load is applied to each of the four system points equally out-of-plane, but unequally in-plane.

The load acts at the center point of the system but there is distance of between the load and the thrust. The load is applied equally to the two leading rollers and to the two lagging rollers during acceleration.

Sponsored Recommendations

How BASF turns data into savings

May 7, 2024
BASF continuously monitors the health of 63 substation assets — with Schneider’s Service Bureau and EcoStruxure™ Asset Advisor. ►Learn More: https://www.schn...

Agile design thinking: A key to operation-level digital transformation acceleration

May 7, 2024
Digital transformation, aided by agile design thinking, can reduce obstacles to change. Learn about 3 steps that can guide success.

Can new digital medium voltage circuit breakers help facilities reduce their carbon footprint?

May 7, 2024
Find out how facility managers can easily monitor energy usage to create a sustainable, decarbonized environment using digital MV circuit breakers.

The Digital Thread: End-to-End Data-Driven Manufacturing

May 1, 2024
Creating a Digital Thread by harnessing end-to-end manufacturing data is providing unprecedented opportunities to create efficiencies in the world of manufacturing.

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Machine Design, create an account today!