Designing Motion-Control Systems With Electric Cylinders

Jan. 25, 2001
Electric cylinders are relatively inexpensive and easy to program. New options are also shortening design cycles.

Ross Goluba
Product Manager
Industrial Devices Corp.
Petaluma, Calif.

Edited by Miles Budamir

Improvements in dynamic response, force, and environmental parameters let electric cylinders fit applications previously dominated by leak-prone hydraulic and pneumatic linear actuators. Electric cylinders are easy to install, offer longer service life and higher accuracy, and work effectively in a wide variety of sophisticated control systems.

Fast, powerful, and reliable electric cylinders consist of electric motors, belts, and leadscrews that are matched for optimum performance.

Electric cylinders come in a variety of load and speed ratings, lengths, motor types, and load attachments. Their modular design lets them fit a wide range of machines.

Internal construction of a belt-drive electric cylinder

Electric cylinders are often used in simple bang-bang motion control systems where limit switches placed at each end of travel comprise the simplest type of control.

Analog control systems employ a feedback sensor to determine the actual position of the load. This more accurate, absolute closed-loop positioning system easily interfaces with a variety of sensors, PLCs, and PCs.

Speed-thrust curves help select a best-fit electric cylinder.

Motion-control systems that require linear movement can be built around a variety of different actuators. The most common types fall into linear actuators, linear motors, and precision positioning tables. Linear actuators, generally the lowest cost approach, can be hydraulic, pneumatic, or electromechanical. Each comes with advantages and drawbacks, so their use depends on the specific application.

Hydraulic cylinders, for example, can handle high loads and generate forces up to several tons. But they're not so good at accurate load positioning. This task requires relatively expensive position sensors and electrohydraulic servovalve controls. Hydraulic systems also tend to leak which contaminates the work area.

By comparison, pneumatic cylinders are primarily used when light loads must be repeatedly moved between fixed positions. Pneumatics have high-speed capabilities, reaching speeds to 200 in./sec. Because of these qualities, they are generally used for simple bang-bang type applications where multiple positioning or accurate velocity control is not required.

To overcome the limitations of pneumatics and hydraulics, more applications are using electromechanical linear actuators. They consist of an electric motor mounted to either a screw or belt-drive system. These actuators generally come with rods or without. Rodless actuators guide and support a load with a carriage that moves along the actuator body. A built in bearing system lets them function as the primary load support. They can serve a single axis or be assembled into mulitaxis cartesian systems. They are not suited for high thrust applications because the carriage is offset from the linear bearing and drive system of the actuator. Where high thrust is needed, rod-type actuators are applied.

Rod-type actuators, commonly referred to as electric cylinders, are similar in configuration and appearance to hydraulic or pneumatic cylinders. They have no internal linear bearings, so the load must be externally supported or the cylinder must be mounted on a pivot to keep the force in line with the thrust tube. Small side loads can be tolerated. An advantage of electric cylinders over rodless actuators is their ability to extend into a work area and then retract, freeing the area for subsequent operations. Also, protective boots mounted on thrust rods keep contaminants out of the cylinder body. This allows assigning an IP65 rating, making them suitable for reliable operation in dirty or wet environments.

Electric-cylinder advances
More machine builders are moving away from hydraulics and pneumatics in favor of more versatile electromechanical solutions. This has encouraged manufacturers to further improve the load-handling capability and accuracy of their products, while making them smaller and easier to size and install. Manufacturers generally offer several basic models to cover a wide range of thrusts with options such as rod ends, mounting supports, linear potentiometers, and environmentaloriented options. The options let machine designers choose the cylinder that fits in their machine, rather than designing the machine around the cylinder.

Electric cylinders generate the highest thrust among the various types of electromechanical linear actuators. This is because the thrust tube is directly in line with the screw and nut. Some cylinders can handle high loads which rival the capabilities of hydraulic actuators. Although at high thrust ranges, hydraulics tend to be more cost effective.

The most common applications for electric cylinders are in the range of 6,000 lb or less. Electric cylinders also combine high speed with high accuracy, repeatability, and reliability. Maximum speeds can be as high as 50 in./sec and controlled accurately.

Cylinders are usually driven by stepper motors, servomotors, and dc motors. Each has benefits. Selecting one depends on the load, duty cycle, repeatability, and flexibility requirements. The cylinders' accuracy and repeatability depend on the mechanics and motor. Repeatability can be as low as ±0.0005 in. Controls for electric cylinders range from simple pushbuttons to more complex programmable multiaxis motion controllers. These can interface easily to a variety of operator and machine interfaces such as simple manual thumbwheel switches or more sophisticated programmable-logic controllers and personal computers. This control flexibility gives designers a wide choice, allowing them to weigh the cost and benefits of each solution.

Anatomy of an electric cylinder
An electric cylinder consists of an electric motor, gear reduction or timing-belt reduction, coupled to an Acme or recirculating ball screw. The motor can be attached directly to the screw, in an in-line configuration, or mounted on the side of the housing and coupled to the screw through a gear or belt drive. The latter mounting is called a parallel configuration. The thrust tube attaches to the nut on the screw and is kept from rotating with a guide bearing. The thrust tube attaches to the load by the rod ends, which could be a male or female thread, spherical joint, or a clevis.

The operating principle of a belt-drive electric cylinder is fairly straightforward. In the example illustrated, power applied to the electric motor turns a belt and pulley system, which in turn rotates the ball screw. The rotating ball screw moves the ball nut, which cannot rotate, to move forward or backward along the screw axis. The thrust tube either extends forward from the cylinder housing or retracts inside the housing.

Electric cylinders can be mounted rigidly or on a pivot. In the pivoting style, the actuator mounts with a clevis or trunnion. The load also mounts on a pivot and moves along an arc. Application examples include lid lifters, conveyor diverter gates, pivoting rollers, and other applications requiring arc-path motion. In rigid mounts, end angle brackets or side lugs secure the cylinder. Threaded rod ends are preferred when the load is rigidly mounted to the thrust tube. By comparison, rodless actuators, positioning tables, and linear motors can only be rigidly mounted because they move and position the payload along the body of the mechanics.

Manufacturers of electric cylinders typically offer designers a choice of permanent-magnet brush type dc motors, stepper motors, or brushless servomotors. Permanent magnet, brush-type dc motors cost the least. They have modest controllability, and only position to switches or hard stops.

More expensive stepper motors offer programmable positioning. They are repeatable and can be programmed in microsteps, typically in the range of 25,000 to 50,000 steps/rev. Acceleration, velocity, and position can be programmed by the motion controller. Steppers are open loop, which means the motion controller does not sense a stalled motor. However, an encoder can be installed on the rear of the motor to make it a closed-loop system.

The most costly, but highest performance motor is the brushless servomotor. Servos have the same programmability as stepper motors, but are inherently closed-loop systems. They produce higher torque and speed, so they can accelerate faster and handle larger loads than any other type of electric motor. Moreover, they are compact for their power and run cooler than a stepper motor.

When choosing between an Acme or a recirculating ball screw, consider such factors as duty cycle, backdriving, cost, and speed. The efficiency of ball screws is around 90% which lets them turn most of the motor's torque into actual force. Also, ball screws are 100% duty-cycle rated making them the only drive choice in designs that require high duty cycles or continuous operation. Their high efficiency gives them a low back-drive force. This means an external brake is normally required where loads must be held in place after removing power from the motor. Ball screws are more expensive than Acme screws, but typically only add about 5% to the cost of an electric cylinder.

With efficiency only in the 50 to 60% range, Acme leadscrews are not suitable for continuous operation. Friction and the heat generated in the leadscrew and drive-nut assembly are the main sources of energy loss. The duty cycle must be limited to 60% or less to avoid overheating. However, Acme screw drives are self-locking. When the power is removed from the motor, the Acme screw holds the load in place. Generally, an Acme-screw drive can hold up to 20 times greater load without backdriving than a similar ball-screw drive.

Several key parameters — thrust, duty cycle, peak speed, and stroke length — must be determined before selecting an electric cylinder. The maximum thrust the cylinder produces must overcome gravitational, frictional, acceleration, and applied forces of the load:

Tm = Fg + Ff + Fac + Fap,

where Tm = maximum thrust, lb; Fg = gravity, lb; Ff = frictional force, lb; Fac = acceleration force, lb; and Fap = applied force, lb. Usually, a 10 to 30% safety factor is added to the required thrust rating. The value also depends on the type of motor employed.

The cylinder's peak speed rating depends on the motion profile, whether triangular or trapezoidal. In the case of the trapezoidal profile, peak speed is 1.5 times average speed. Average speed is determined by dividing the distance the load must travel by the time needed to complete the motion.

Speed-thrust curves provided by cylinder manufacturers can help select the proper unit. Doing so requires knowing design values such as accuracy and repeatability. The types of leadscrews and motors available for a cylinder family are determined while selecting the component.

Several stroke lengths are available for each electric cylinder. However, before selecting the stroke, add safety areas at each end of travel (which exceed the cylinder stopping distance) to the distance that the load must travel. Higher speeds call for longer stopping distances and longer safety areas. After verifying that speed and thrust are not limited by the actuator stroke length, select the mounting and other options.

Several control-system architectures can be used depending on the required positioning accuracy, speed, degree of flexibility, and budget. Dc motor controls, for instance, provide the most economical option for applications where only one or two speeds are required for each direction, and the load stops at the same point in each cycle. The user interface can be as simple as a pushbutton switch. A wide range of limit switches or analog positioning packages are readily available. Two industry-standard control signals are used for the interface: 0 to 10 V or 4 to 20 mA.

Servomotor and stepper-motor controls add flexibility to a design. For example, numerous stopping points can be preprogrammed, force can be controlled, motion profiles can be customized, and keypads and displays can be used as an interface with a computer to control the system. When high accuracy, repeatability, and resolution are required, use a servomotor or stepper-motor control system.

More sophisticated controls allow adding more options to the motion-control system to satisfy the needs of the overall machine. Common practice is to install an end-of-travel limit switch to prevent damage to the load or the cylinder when it can extend beyond its safe-operating zone. The switch signals the controller that the cylinder is approaching a set point so the controller can stop the cylinder motion before possible impact. Position sensors used in these limit switches contain mechanical reed or Hall-effect switches. Both are available in a normally-open or normally-closed configuration. The Hall-effect switches are available with either current sinking (npn transistor) or current sourcing (pnp transistor) output stages.

Choosing the control system goes hand-in-hand with selecting the motor. The limit-switch control, the analog position control, and the edge-guide control are examples of widely used dc-motor controls suitable for applications requiring a few stopping positions and a simple motion profile. More sophisticated stepper-motor controllers, microstepping drives, and general-purpose controllers are available for systems requiring higher levels of accuracy, repeatability, and programmability. Analog and digital servosystems are available that include a variety of servodrives, programmable servodrives, and motion controllers that offer a wide range of performance and flexibility for the most demanding applications.

Sponsored Recommendations

The entire spectrum of drive technology

June 5, 2024
Read exciting stories about all aspects of maxon drive technology in our magazine.


May 15, 2024
Production equipment is expensive and needs to be protected against input abnormalities such as voltage, current, frequency, and phase to stay online and in operation for the ...

Solenoid Valve Mechanics: Understanding Force Balance Equations

May 13, 2024
When evaluating a solenoid valve for a particular application, it is important to ensure that the valve can both remain in state and transition between its de-energized and fully...

Solenoid Valve Basics: What They Are, What They Do, and How They Work

May 13, 2024
A solenoid valve is an electromechanical device used to control the flow of a liquid or gas. It is comprised of two features: a solenoid and a valve. The solenoid is an electric...

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Machine Design, create an account today!