Machinedesign 2676 42 Js Indy500 224by125 0

Indy Car Racing Beefs Up Competition for Sluggish Economy

May 19, 2009
Despite measures to keep racing costs down, changes to tires, clutches, and exhaust systems could spice up competition throughout this year’s Indy Car Series.

Authored by:
Jessica Shapiro
[email protected]

Key points
• New Honda exhaust systems cut down on exhaust noise and temper whine without robbing engine power.
• Alternate tires with better grip and shorter life are adding a new wrinkle to the IndyCar Series’ road and street races.
• The IRL, engine OEMs, and racingengine designers are collaborating on new engine specs to be implemented in 2012.

Firestone Racing,;/
Honda Racing Development,
Indy Racing League,

When the flag goes down on the 93rd Indianapolis 500 May 24, it will be amid much fanfare for the history of the race and the Brickyard where it runs. Officials have declared 2009 as the start of Indy’s “Centennial Era,” during which both the race and the racetrack will celebrate hundredth anniversaries. But even with all that history behind it, the Indy Racing League (IRL) is facing more uncertainty than ever.

Although auto racing remains popular, some critics question the usefulness of expensive car races during an economic downturn. Others complain that the powerful engines propelling these cars are too polluting and that race officials don’t do enough to promote energy efficiency and emissions reduction.

Nevertheless, open-spec series like Le Mans have been making headlines as teams deploy fuel-efficiency innovations and even alternative fuels. Formula One has been struggling to determine how to keep its technology relevant while maintaining a level playing field and keeping costs in check, and similar issues face the IRL.

The 2009 season is the second in which IndyCar teams and former Champ Car teams are racing under one banner. Predictably, the teams that transitioned from Champ Car struggled to stay competitive in 2008, especially on the many oval tracks the IndyCar Series uses.

For 2009, there are a few rule changes that officials hope will keep competition interesting, some of which come directly from the former Champ Car circuit.

Tires could wake up competition
One such change to the IndyCar circuit is tire provider Firestone Racing’s introduction of alternate tire sets on road and street courses. In addition to the six full sets of regular dry-weather tires Firestone allots each team, racers will get three sets of alternate tires marked with red sidewalls. The red tires have softer tread which gives them better grip, lets drivers brake later in corners, and permits faster cornering and more overtaking. The downside, of course, is that the tires wear faster, so teams will have to deploy their limited supply carefully.

Teams must run each type of tire for a minimum of two laps during the race itself, but it is up to them to plan a tire-use strategy that covers practice, qualifying, and racing. Other than the two-lap requirement, the only restriction on tire deployment is that teams must reserve at least one set of new alternate tires for the race itself.

Firestone parent company Bridgestone introduced alternate tires to the Champ Car World Series at the 2004 Long Beach Grand Prix. The competition enhancer has also found its way into Formula One racing.

Firestone and the IRL hope the addition will increase overtaking and add another dimension to fans’ viewing experience. They believe the “reds” will play a key role in each street or road race’s qualifying system. Teams will have to choose whether they want to use the faster alternate tires in the first qualifying segment to assure themselves a top-12 position, in subsequent segments if they advance that far, in all of qualifying, or not at all. Teams making it to the final segment, called the Firestone Fast Six Shootout, get an additional set of primary and alternate tires to use solely during that portion of qualifying.

Firestone already formulates individual tire compounds to meet each course’s surface properties, banking and turn angles, and track width. (See sidebar.)

“The short ovals of Richmond, Milwaukee, and Iowa are closely related in length but light years apart in the demands they place on race tires,” says a Firestone spokesperson. “The six 1.5-mile Speedways — Chicagoland, Homestead-Miami, Kansas, Kentucky, Texas Motor, and Twin Ring Motegi — necessitate consistent tire performance at constant high speeds. The permanent road courses — Infineon Raceway, Mid- Ohio Sports Car Course, and Watkins Glen International — and temporary street circuits — Long Beach, St. Petersburg, and Toronto, and the Edmonton City Centre Airport — each require different race tires than those used on the ovals to permit both left and right-hand turns.”

How much lap time could a driver shave off with the red-sidewall tires?

“We’re being a little bit private with our predictions,” says Al Speyer, executive director at Firestone Racing. “We found in the past that when we say the reds are about a half-second faster, everybody comes back and tells us ‘Oh, they’re about a halfsecond faster.’

“We are going to run different primary and alternate tires at each of the street courses, and we’re also adjusting the gap between what we think the standard tires will run and the alternate red-sidewall tires will run. So it’s not going to be the same time difference at each of the tracks.”

In addition to spicing up competition, Firestone is using the alternate tire plan for research and development that might have wider applications. Speyer says some of the alternate tires will have proprietary technology that could lead to better-gripping, slower- wearing tires for passenger cars.

All quiet on pit row
Another change, one which may affect fans more than the teams, is the new exhaust systems the cars are sporting this year. Engine supplier Honda Performance Development (HPD) added a mechanical silencer, first developed to meet noise restrictions in the American Le Mans Series. A bolt-on exhaust system with a new header and muffler design is part of the package.

The changes are said to cut by around 10 dB without hindering engine power. The exhaust tone may also lose some of its harshness.

Roger Griffiths with HPD says changes let IndyCars sound more like they did in the mid-1990s when rules allowed turbocharged engines. “You could actually carry on a conversation in pit lane with your headsets on,” Griffiths said of his experience during off-season testing at Indy. “It was so refreshing.”

Some IndyCar teams agree. “The engine tone seems to be more acceptable to people trackside and anything that is good for the fans is good for the sport,” says Brian Lisles, general manager of Newman/Haas/Lanigan Racing.

The change brings noise levels at IndyCar Series races closer to those fans experienced in the former Champ Car Series. It also helps the IRL meet city noise ordinances when the cars compete on temporary street courses, many of which were added to the schedule under the reunification of the two series.

A clutch decision
One other rule change this year is said to have been proposed by some teams that transitioned from the Champ Car Series. Teams can now choose to replace their cars’ sintered powder-metal clutch with a carbon-clutch system similar to that permitted by Champ Car.

The carbon units costs more up-front than sintered clutches, but are said to need less maintenance over the course of the season. Because carbon clutches are lightweight, they have low inertia and may permit faster gear changes. The can also withstand longer exposures to high temperatures without distorting.

Teams that are adopting the new clutches hope to spend less time servicing and repairing the transmission throughout the season.

Newman/Haas/Lanigan Racing, a former Champ Car team, evaluated the new clutch. According to General Manager Lisles, “Total lifetime cost is very similar for the two clutches.”

Time for an engine change?
Engines in passenger cars are evolving quickly these days to meet government-imposed emissions and efficiency requirements. Free of such restrictions, and with much larger budgets than the average passenger-car buyer, racing engines in some series have been slow to make the same changes.

The IRL is now working with OEMs and race-engine designers to develop new IndyCar Series engine specs that could be released sometime this year. The goal was to have new engines in the IndyCar Series for the 2011 season, but officials recently said they would likely delay rollout to 2012.

Potential participants have held several roundtable meetings so far. Although they have made no commitment to continue with the process, HPD, Audi, Fiat Powertrain Technologies, Porsche, and Volkswagen have all been involved in the discussion at some point. Six specialty race-engine-design companies have also joined the working meetings.

Many details are still being ironed out, but the new engine will stick to a four-stroke cycle with four valves per cylinder. A dual-overhead cam will replace the current engine’s four camshafts. Cylinder count will fall from the current V8 configuration, but four and six-cylinder designs are both in play.

The engine will continue to use 100% ethanol, and it will upgrade fuel delivery to direct injection. Recently, direct injection has made its mark in higher-end passenger engines as a way to maintain power while improving fuel efficiency and minimizing combustion-generated emissions.

OEMs have also downsized some passenger-car engines and added turbochargers to provide the low-end power drivers expect. Following the trend, IndyCar will downsize its current 3.5-liter engine to under 2.0 liters. Rules will permit a single turbocharger; current engines are normally aspirated.

The new engines are expected to go 3,750 miles between rebuilds under race conditions, more than double the current 1,400-mile lifespan. IRL says it will soften the new engine’s cost impact on teams with an engine lease ceiling.

Although getting teams to adapt to a new engine in a slow economy might seem like a tough sell, IndyCar Series teams appear to trust that the IRL will take steps to keep costs in check.

“The costs of the engines and the level of investment the teams need to put into them should not change,” predicted Tom Brown, engineer for Sarah Fisher Racing. “The league has a very good control on what costs can be passed onto the teams and is aware of how much the teams can absorb in terms of development and test cost.”

Like the current engines, design will be fixed by a five-year sealed engine homologation process. The process will most likely define areas for annual updates, however.

Ask the race engineer
Race engineer Tom Brown from Sarah Fisher Racing and Brian Lisles, general manager of Newman/Haas/ Lanigan Racing spoke to MACHINE DESIGN about the present conditions and future direction of the race circuit.



 Race Engineer Tom Brown consults with Sarah Fisher of Sarah Fisher racing.

 The new engine specs
Lisles predicts, “The [new] engine will save money if IRL mandates a minimum engine life. If it is turbocharged, the engine will have the potential to improve racing by increasing opportunities for cars to overtake one another. But the engine will have little effect on how we run our team.”

“New engines or new chassis always present a level of change and approach for the race teams, and this is always welcomed,” says Brown. “Any change provides opportunities to explore new engineering solutions. This is what drives the best teams, and we are looking forward to it. We would like to be part of any development program. At the moment we have no specific timelines.”

IndyCar and Champ Car merged just before the 2008 season. Teams like Newman/Haas/Lanigan Racing which had long been successful in the Champ Car series faced some adjustments when making the transition to IndyCar.

“The schedule [in IndyCar] is much more time compressed [than in Champ Car] so car prep needs to be done in less time. Also, more significant changes need to be made to the car for different venues, so the logistics are much more demanding and more manpower is needed,” says Lisles.

Brown agrees. “Most of the teams, managers, engineers and mechanics have worked in other series. It was just a matter of adapting and learning the speci fics and details of the new formula. Each formula has some areas where the details matter more than others. The ‘transition’ teams [moving over from Champ Car] had to pay attention to controlling drag on the oval courses. Most have now figured out these minute details.”

The economy
Lisles says, “The current economic situation has seriously impacted the team. We have cut back in all areas of our operations and continue to seek cost savings.”

“Teams must work within their budgets and get the best value for dollars spent,” agrees Brown. “Obviously the economy has affected racing in all formulas, but the league has produced sound testing and race rules that help keep the running costs within reason.

“Most of the IRL races are now two-day events, with limited running before the race. This puts an emphasis on team preparation prior to the events. No longer can we just test for days and days prior to events. We must be much more efficient with our test and preparation time. The reduced running effectively focuses the work load. It makes the good teams much more efficient and cuts down on waste.”

Technology development
“All engineers want an open rule book, with unlimited resources, and unlimited scope to explore. There may come a time in the future that we can get that, but right now we must act in a responsible manner and work within the resources the economy provides,” says Brown.

“We would like to see more freedom for innovation,” agrees Lisles, “although that may be difficult to accomplish within the current economic climate.”

However, Brown argues, a tight budget is not a bad thing. “It can make us more efficient with our time and resources. The hybrids, KERS [kinetic-energy recovery systems], and other energy-efficient systems can be argued to have been developed to meet a more exacting environmental and energy-conscious industry. These systems may not have been looked at so closely without the economic environment we live in right now,” he says.

Sponsored Recommendations

From concept to consumption: Optimizing success in food and beverage

April 9, 2024
Identifying opportunities and solutions for plant floor optimization has never been easier. Download our visual guide to quickly and efficiently pinpoint areas for operational...

A closer look at modern design considerations for food and beverage

April 9, 2024
With new and changing safety and hygiene regulations at top of mind, its easy to understand how other crucial aspects of machine design can get pushed aside. Our whitepaper explores...

Cybersecurity and the Medical Manufacturing Industry

April 9, 2024
Learn about medical manufacturing cybersecurity risks, costs, and threats as well as effective cybersecurity strategies and essential solutions.

Condition Monitoring for Energy and Utilities Assets

April 9, 2024
Condition monitoring is an essential element of asset management in the energy and utilities industry. The American oil and gas, water and wastewater, and electrical grid sectors...

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Machine Design, create an account today!